Boles criticised from left and right

Last week, I blogged about Planning Minister Nick Boles’s call to build over the countryside. I pointed out that it makes no sense to pave over open lands, which would be lost forever, when there is so much capacity to get building within our existing cities.

Since then, Boles’s suggestion has elicited condemnation from both left and right. Yesterday, the Observer‘s front page featured Andrew Motion, head of the Campaign to Protect Rural England, lambasting Boles’s comments as “incredible irresponsible”. Motion said, “we know what will happen if this goes through: builders will slap up new estates in the most desirable places; they will snap up prime land in addition to the vast tracts of undeveloped land they own already.”

The criticism heightened this morning, when The Times reported that Boles is quickly becoming a “hate figure” even within his own party., and the minister was denounced by Tory MP Bob Stewart.

The most astute article on the dangerous implications of Boles’s comments was an editorial from the Telegraph, which characterised them as a “recipe for senseless sprawl”. Like others, the piece raised questions about Boles’s fitness for the job, pointing out that he “has given the impression of being someone who sees planning as an impediment to prosperity rather than a balancing act between the competing requirements of economic growth and preserving the countryside for future generations.”

The rounding opposition sparked by Boles’s statement is reassuring. The planning minister offers a vision of an England peppered with unsustainable housing estates, where people rely on their car for everything from getting to work to the weekly shop. This clearly isn’t an England the people want.

Boles would turn open countryside into unsustainable housing estates connected to amenities and jobs by car

Boles would turn green fields into unsustainable housing estates connected to amenities and jobs by car

Advertisements

About nickygavron

Former Deputy Mayor for London, London Assembly Member, Chair of Planning Committee, and Labour Spokesperson for Planning
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

One Response to Boles criticised from left and right

  1. Paul says:

    What about unsustainable (in terms of their carbon footprint and lack of energy) wind farms? I’d say they were worse than the sprawl that Boles speaks of. A blight on the landscape loved only by those of a religious persuasion who follow the holy order of climate change fanatics and rich landowners.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s